Pelicans Need Zion Williamson To Use Harsh Criticism As Fuel

In the NBA’s new in-season tournament, players received more attention than usual during this part of the regular season. One standout was Tyrese Haliburton, who made his TNT debut, captivating audiences with his dynamic play that propelled the Pacers into the finals, potentially elevating his star status.

Conversely, Zion Williamson faced criticism for his underwhelming performance. His team, the Pelicans, suffered a heavy defeat against the Lakers in the semifinals. Williamson only managed 13 points, two rebounds, and three assists in a 44-point loss, sparking widespread criticism, a noise he’s used to hearing long before he reached the NBA.

“It’s been like that since I was 16 years old – since I came onto the scene,” Williamson told The Athletic. “If I want to be one of the best players in the league, if we don’t win in a big moment or if something bad happens, that’s to be expected.”

NBA legend Shaquille O’Neal, commenting post-game on TNT, compared his early career challenges to Williamson’s, noting a lack of effort in creating scoring opportunities. He observed Williamson’s absence of a demanding presence on the court.

“I had the same problem my first and second year. I thought I was running hard,” O’Neal said. “Because my talent’s going to get me 20 [points]. When I started getting to 30–40, it’s because I started doing certain things. … He doesn’t create easy points for himself. … He doesn’t demand the ball. … He doesn’t have that look like, ‘I’m the greatest ever.’ I know a look when I see it.”

Christian Clark, a Pelicans reporter for the Times-Picayune, referenced team sources expressing frustration over Williamson’s ignored advice on improving his fitness.

“The Pelicans have repeatedly stressed to Williamson that his diet and conditioning need to improve,” Clark wrote. “Williamson, multiple team sources have told The Times-Picayune, ‘doesn’t listen.'”

ESPN analyst and former teammate JJ Redick also voiced concerns, pointing out Williamson’s lack of commitment to his fitness and career.

“He’s still not in shape despite everything that he’s gone through, despite numerous conversations with legends of the game about being in shape,” Redick said.

Despite these critiques, Williamson has had moments of brilliance in the NBA, averaging 22.2 points, 5.6 rebounds, and 4.8 assists per game. However, his inconsistency and injury history have hindered his ability to meet the high expectations set for him. Now in his fifth professional year, Williamson’s conditioning remains a key issue, highlighted by team management, NBA legends, and former teammates.

Acknowledging the need for improvement after the semifinal loss, Williamson has shown signs of addressing his fitness, as Pelicans president David Griffin noted. However, questions remain about the consistency of his efforts.

“If it comes from a place where they just wanna see me do better, thank you,” Williamson said. “But if it comes from anywhere else, everybody is entitled to their own opinion. Can’t control that.”

Williamson’s situation not only affects him but also the Pelicans. The team, which includes talented players like CJ McCollum and Brandon Ingram, has struggled when Williamson is on the court. Trade rumors involving Williamson have circulated, raising questions about the team’s future composition.

As the Pelicans strive for higher achievements, Williamson’s inconsistent performances become increasingly conspicuous. His path forward is clear: demonstrate a consistent commitment to his fitness and skill to silence critics and fulfill his potential.