Yankees will likely be without their third baseman on Opening Day

The Yankees were already thin at third base with the news that Oswald Peraza would miss a good chunk of time recovering from a shoulder injury. Now, they find out that DJ LeMahieu likely won’t be ready for Opening Day, although that doesn’t mean it’ll be an IL situation either. He has progressed well, doing some light jogging and even taking defensive reps at the hot corner, but the likelihood that he’ll be ramped up in time is low, and the Yankees don’t want to push a foot injury further.

We saw how foot issues and playing through injury have affected LeMahieu in the past, experiencing a dramatic slump in August and September back in 2022 before being shut down for the postseason. It took him the first half of last season to get his swing back into shape, and this should prevent the veteran infielder from developing bad habits to compensate for an injury. In the meantime, this presents two questions about what the Yankees will do to replace him as he’s both their third baseman and leadoff hitter.

Fellow infielder Gleyber Torres could be the best leadoff option they have, as he’s one of the best all-around hitters in the game. The 27-year-old is coming off a great season last year, smacking 25 home runs with a 123 wRC+, and cutting his strikeout rate down to a measly 14.6%. The improved plate discipline and feel for contact make him arguably the best option for the role on the team, even when LeMahieu is healthy. His .273 average and 10% walk rate make him capable of both creating hits and being patient enough to work his walks.

The Yankees have also begun leading him off in LeMahieu’s absence, so it’ leads me to believe that Torres is their choice in the meantime. As for who plays third base, Oswaldo Cabrera and Jahmai Jones are the remaining options on the 40-man roster with MLB experience and an extensive track record at third base. Kevin Smith, who was a Non-Roster Invite, could also make the team but hasn’t necessarily had strong numbers in his showings. Perhaps the Yankees look to an external addition to try and supplement their bench in the meantime.

It’s unclear whether DJ LeMahieu will hit the IL or not, but for now, the Yankees will need a third baseman to play on Opening Day, and that answer is murky.